HELP! - UNKNOWN LOUISE RAYNER PAINTING! - UPDATE!

Can anyone identify this painting's location? It could have been painted between 1850 and 1920, though 1870 to 1900 is probably a closer bracket. If, like us, you start from not knowing, it's trickier than it seems, and unfortunately the image is not quite sharp and cannot be usefully enlarged.

Our first reaction was Ludlow's Bull Ring but the buildings to the left are completely wrong. Then you look at the church with its crenellated top, corner pinnacles and pointed roof. Sounds like it should reduce the candidates? Well, it should, but while the pointed roof isn't always there, the rest of the pattern is surprisingly widespread. That said, Louise may have slightly adjusted the church's position to give it more visibility or prominence.

Despite the pantiles (noted below), we've had someone make a case for Chester - which was Louise's base after all - and the church promptly suggests St Peter's. However, there can then be only one location for the painting (north from Watergate Street), and the fall of the land argues against that. Unless someone can overturn that objection, we believe that this is not Chester.

So what remains that aids identification?

1. The road at left is a normal road, with this area widened to provide an original market area or possibly a market overspill, though the perimeter buildings indicate that it would have been there a century or two at least.

2. There is what looks like a brick market archway at left, and this may still survive, or at least might appear in town history albums.

3. The road continues up the hill to pass near the church, and this locational feature has already ruled out several candidates (though its position may be wrong).

4. The main building in the painting has a pantile roof, and others may have one as well. Pantiles originally came into Britain from Holland and Belgium as ship's ballast from around the 17th century, and can be found in counties down the east coast from Scotland to Kent. Some also came in to a few western ports, notably Bridgwater, Somerset, which developed a considerable industry serving adjacent south-western counties. But tiles are heavy, and before mass transport arrived they didn't travel into other parts of the country.
unknown location

If you think you know where the location is (and we'd be glad of likely dates, if you can suggest them) we would appreciate your suggestions by email to dudleymall@dudleymall.co.uk. There is no prize, but if you wish, we will add your name to the caption as the one who solved the puzzle!

Copyright © 2012 DudleyMall.

    Email DudleyMall at: dudleymall@dudleymall.co.uk
DudleyMall, 62 Gervase Drive, Dudley, West Midlands DY1 4AT